Skip to main content
Who Makes The
BEST COFFEE
US Brand Directory
South Orange, NJ, New Jersey · Specialty Coffee Brand Deep Dive

Elitist Coffee

Editorial sacred-geometry artwork for Elitist Coffee; not a documentary photograph
IndependentRoasts its own coffeeSourcing: Limited public info
TagsElitist CoffeeNew Jersey coffee roastersPapua New GuineaIndependentRoasts in-house
Visit Elitist Coffee's site

Elitist Coffee is a Black and mother-daughter-owned specialty coffee house located in South Orange, New Jersey, that distinguishes itself through a commitment to small-batch, weekly roasting. The shop operates as a vibrant community hub, offering a welcoming, inclusive space that hosts diverse events including live music, poetry readings, comedy nights, and book clubs. By utilizing an in-house water purification system for all beverages, the brand emphasizes a meticulous approach to quality control. Beyond its role as a café, the business functions as a versatile venue with a business center and comfortable seating, positioning itself as a local destination that prioritizes genuine hospitality and high-quality, ethically sourced coffee.

Ownership
Elitist Coffee is an independent, family-owned business operated by a mother-daughter team, Sharon and Shauna Arnette.
Founded
2022
Roasting
Reported to roast in-house.
What it's known for
The brand is known for its community-focused atmosphere, hosting local events like live music and poetry, and its commitment to using purified water in all its brewing processes.
Sourcing countries
Papua New Guinea
Farm-level sourcing
The brand mentions sourcing from farmers committed to ecosystem health and fair labor practices, but does not provide specific farm or producer names on their website. They offer international blends and single-origin options, such as Papua New Guinea Tsekaka Peaberry.
Notable coffees
  • — Papua New Guinea Tsekaka Peaberry
Documented coffee offerings

Coffees researched from Elitist Coffee

These are examples recorded during editorial research. They are not a live product feed. The coffee, lot, price, and availability may have changed. We have not necessarily brewed these coffees ourselves.

House Blend

Ethiopia, Uganda, Nicaragua

This blend features flavors of dark cherry, chocolate, and orange peel with a rich, smooth body and a sweet finish.

Original roaster or listing source

External customer, cafe, marketplace, and class ratings are not comparable measures of the quality of an individual coffee. We do not convert them into original tasting scores or brand-wide star ratings. Our independent reviews are published separately after a coffee has actually been brewed and evaluated.

Verify original product sources

Retailer information: Elitist Coffee

Documented physical retailers
Elitist Coffee
Historical source note (not live inventory): The brand operates a physical specialty coffee house in South Orange, NJ, where they serve and sell their roasted coffee.
Physical
Documented online sources
Elitist Coffee's online shop
Historical source note (not live inventory): The brand offers online ordering for their coffee products through their Toast-powered platform.
Website

I was able to verify that Elitist Coffee sells its products directly through its physical cafe location in South Orange, NJ, and via its own online ordering platform hosted on Toast; no third-party retail distribution was found.

These references come from public store locators, retailer listings and brand materials. Last checked Oct 22, 2026. They are research links, not proof of current stock or a buying recommendation. Verify availability, price and location directly with the source.
In the news

Recent news and media coverage about Elitist Coffee, as documented by outside outlets. We link to the original reporting and do not rewrite or endorse it.

Sources used in this deep dive
Research disclosure — this profile was compiled from public online sources on 2026-10-06. This company overview is not a tasting review. Original tasting reviews are labeled separately when they exist. Ownership, roasting and sourcing details are attributed to documented sources. While the brand mentions sourcing from farmers committed to fair labor and ecosystem health, it does not publish a list of specific sourcing countries or verifiable details regarding formal philanthropy programs.

Your coffee interests. Every section.

Learn something new, follow the people behind your cup, or explore by flavor and tags.