Skip to main content
Who Makes The
BEST COFFEE
US Brand Directory
Mackinac Island, Michigan, Michigan · Specialty Coffee Brand Deep Dive

Lucky Bean Coffeehouse

Editorial sacred-geometry artwork for Lucky Bean Coffeehouse; not a documentary photograph
IndependentNamed roasting partner: Creation Coffee Co.Sourcing: Limited public info
TagsLucky Bean CoffeehouseMichigan coffee roastersGuatemalaEthiopiaIndependent
Visit Lucky Bean Coffeehouse's site

Lucky Bean Coffeehouse is a seasonal specialty coffee shop located on historic Market Street on Mackinac Island. Established in 2011, the shop operates from spring through fall, serving a variety of espresso-based beverages and curated coffee blends to locals and island visitors.

Ownership
Lucky Bean Coffeehouse is an independent, family-owned business operated by Carolyn May, who opened the shop in 2011.
Founded
2011
Roasting
Named roasting partner: Creation Coffee Co.. Other roasting arrangements are unverified.
What it's known for
Serving as a popular seasonal coffee hub on Mackinac Island, known for its espresso-based specialty drinks and signature 'Island Originals' menu.
Sourcing countries
Guatemala · Ethiopia
Farm-level sourcing
The brand sources its coffee through a roasting partner and does not provide specific farm or producer details for its offerings. Their current retail coffee selection consists of blends, such as the Restless Blend, which combines beans from Guatemala and Ethiopia.
Notable coffees
  • — Restless Blend
  • — Love Potion #9
In the news

Recent news and media coverage about Lucky Bean Coffeehouse, as documented by outside outlets. We link to the original reporting and do not rewrite or endorse it.

2025-12-03 · YourErie.com
Lucky Bean expands with new West 38th Street location

Lucky Bean, a specialty coffee shop that launched its first brick-and-mortar location in Erie, Pennsylvania, in 2024, opened a second location on West 38th Street in December 2025. Co-founder Frankie Stark emphasized the brand's focus on storytelling and community engagement as key differentiators from larger coffee chains.

Sources used in this deep dive
Research disclosure — this profile was compiled from public online sources on 2026-10-25. This company overview is not a tasting review. Original tasting reviews are labeled separately when they exist. Ownership, roasting and sourcing details are attributed to documented sources. While the brand's website mentions sourcing through a partner, it does not provide detailed information regarding their broader supply chain or specific farm-level relationships.

Your coffee interests. Every section.

Learn something new, follow the people behind your cup, or explore by flavor and tags.